Find something (an idea, a claim, an argument, etc.) in Bulman Ch 1 to disagree with. Explain what it is and shy you disagree with it. Note: If you absolutely can’t find something to disagree with, feel free to write about that situation (why you can’t disagree) or simply discuss something that you found interesting in Ch. 1.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
August 20…Popculture
Was Delaney’s definition of popculture new to you? Comment on your relationship with popculture. Have you been able to find ways to bring an...
-
Was Delaney’s definition of popculture new to you? Comment on your relationship with popculture. Have you been able to find ways to bring an...
-
Find something (an idea, a claim, an argument, etc.) in Bulman Ch 1 to disagree with. Explain what it is and shy you disagree with it. N...
-
What other classes have you had in which individualism was discussed? How was it talked about? Is it seen largely as a good thing or a bad t...
MIkayla Blackman-Jones
ReplyDeleteOne statement I disagreed with while reading Bulman’s first chapter was a statement that he had written on the third page. “Films are located at the center of complex cultural processes”. I can see what he meant here; however, I wouldn’t say that films are the CENTER of how we process culture today. I believe things like your family or even social media seem to have more of an influence than most films. Although films are an influence on how you can see things from a different perspective, I don’t think they always connect to how we as a society see things. He said himself that a lot of movies about high school and middle school are generic. They don’t correctly represent how teenagers and adolescents actually think and act.
I found myself agreeing with most of the points Bulman mentions in chapter 1. My only major critique is not a rebuttal of his points, but rather something I felt was missing. I believe he lacked to provide sufficient nuance or subjective commentary on the fact that box office returns are the only way for a movie studio to gauge audience's resonation with a film. Of course, this is a metric accepted widely for determining how well a film has done (and how much people enjoyed it), but since he's intending to make assumptions about cultural reflection, especially considering his claim that the difference in social classes throughout these film analyses is the *most* influential factor in the entire plot structure and pop-culture relevance, I figure it's worth noting a bit more detail on how the public response can only be measured through financial metrics. I question whether cultural response throughout these social classes was affected by who was and wasn't affluent enough to see a movie, especially when considering older decades (as watching movies at home and even piracy were not as accessible).
ReplyDeleteWhile reading Bulman Ch 1 I couldn't find anything to disagree with. Bulman mentions that high school films share similar characteristics because of that I think it's harder for new high school films to really stand out since they all follow the same theme. The main differences they can really change is how modernized it is with the current society along with some minor changes but generally speaking they have the same theme or message.
ReplyDeleteI found myself somewhat agreeable with what Bulman chapter 1 was arguing about. One statement in particular that I found myself truly agreeing on is the statement located on page 2, “First, films reflect the culture to the extent that the creative artists who imagine and make the films are themselves a product of that culture and are attempting to express something about the social world they inhibit.” I agree with this statement because I believe the first step in producing products of pop culture is to experience it firsthand.
ReplyDeleteI disagree with Bulman’s statement “I suggest that films both reflect and shape culture”. I do not think that this statement is true, especially for the American High School film genre. Most high school films have a complete opposite depiction of what high school culture is truly like, yes he does state this but he still believes that the films have some impact on how society is shaped. On top of that, many high school films have social groups, these groups tend to be categorized. It’s typically the popular girls, jocks, geeks, and alternative individuals. In these films bullying seems to be profound, when in reality bullying is a big deal, but it's not like how it is in movies where the “jocks” only bully the “geeks”. So overall, I do not believe that films shape or reflect culture in any way. I think most films dramatize reality to give people false ideas of life.
ReplyDeleteSomething I found interesting within Bulman's Chapter 1 is the emphasis on the stereotypes associated within films that involve schools. Particularly, the analysis given of the teacher's perspective in these films and how they are usually portrayed as the "hero" in an underfunded school. We often see this character portrayed constantly in films even today. For example, Dead Poets Society, Freedom Writers, Dangerous Minds, etc...It's a constantly repeated. As is Shary's analysis of the archetypes of nerds, jocks, popular girls, and rebels. These are characters we can see all of the time that impact our culture in the US.
ReplyDeleteI did not particularly disagree with anything that Bulman wrote about in this chapter. So, a point of his that I heavily agreed with was the line, "Films teach us who we are as much as they reflect who we are. When we go. to the movies, we absorb messages about the social world in which we live." Almost everyone begins watching movies as just a young kid, and continues watching them throughout all of their formative years. Your brain is very receptive to these types of messages through the media you consume at this age, and this can lead to a lot of the beliefs you have about relationships, other people/cultures, etc. Bulman goes on to say that films show us messages about what makes a hero and what makes a villain, which is also very easy to agree with.
ReplyDelete"...'good teacher' films to be based in schools with poor and working class students...'bad teacher' films are most likely to feature middle class students." I wonder why that is. Its interesting when you bring race into it; from what I've seen, poor and working class students are usually black or poc while the "good teacher" is white, and the middle class students are usually white (the "bad teachers" are often white as well.) Why are the hero teachers/students, "oppressed" students, or protagonists often white in these movies? Is it because Hollywood simply prefers white actors/main characters, or is there a message they're trying to spread?
ReplyDeleteI didn’t really disagree with any of his points since most of his points made sense to me. However, something that I found interesting from this reading was actually something that I never really thought about before, the way how there are correlations on how the teacher is perceived based on the social status of the students. Where good teachers would be present in poor/working class students, while bad teachers would be portrayed mostly for middle-class students. It really was an eye opener, making me really look back and think of any exceptions to this case. After realizing this it feels like it’s such a common trope that I barely noticed.
ReplyDeleteOne thing I disagree with is the idea that movies show us what society is truly like. I do think movies can tell us a lot about what people value or what society thinks is important, but I don't think they're always a good representation of real life. Movies are made to entertain people, so things are usually made out to be more dramatic or exaggerated. I think this is especially true with high school movies because they make popularity, dating, and cliques seem like they're huge parts of people's lives, when that isn't necessarily true. I still think movies can be useful when it comes to understanding society, but I don't think we should assume that what we see in movies is how most people actually experience things.
ReplyDeleteSomething I found interesting from chapter 1 was the suggestion that in order to deal with the complexities and confusion of society and human nature, we re-package it as fiction and break them down into stories which make them more comprehensible; leading to the idea that films can be seen as folk tales or myths. This is interesting to me because the film industry is so subjective, yet, I feel as though the films that tackle really complex relationships between people and society tend to be very critically acclaimed. Although not set in high schools, films such as Good Will Hunting and Dead Poets Society come to mind, which explore themes of trauma, abandonment, mental illness, etc. To round out my point, I believe that films which focus on themes of vulnerability, isolation, and identity formation are so highly acclaimed because they’re relatable to the general public despite socio-economic status, as Bulman suggests is what ties the Hollywood American high school films closest to American culture.
ReplyDeleteIn Bulman, Chapter 1, he says, “Ultimately, it is very difficult to specify exactly how films reflect culture and how they affect it.” I disagree with this idea because I think it is possible to identify the ways films reflect and influence culture. In this statement, he is basically saying that we cannot clearly distinguish how films reflect culture or how they affect it. To me, this seems somewhat contradictory to some of his other points about how much culture and real life are portrayed through film. After all, films are often created to tell a story while still being realistic and relatable to people. They are meant to connect with audiences, which means that elements of real life and culture naturally become part of them. Even the actors who are casted and the roles they play can reflect culture and real-life experiences. For example, government restrictions and the experiences of undocumented immigrants are issues that can be represented through film and can reflect the experiences of Latino communities. I also think films clearly affect culture because of how people respond to them, especially through social media. Nowadays, there is almost always something from a movie or show that people want to cancel, discuss, or speak up about. Films can bring awareness to issues such as the unfair treatment of immigrants, particularly Latinos, as well as many other cultures and communities. Another example could be a Black child going to a very diverse school but still having a name that is stereotypically associated with being Black. This may not have been intentionally given a deeper meaning by the writer or director, but it can still have significance to Black viewers who recognize those cultural connections. The same can be said for a Hispanic character being named Juan, Jesús, or José. Even if the director does not intend the name to have a deeper meaning, it can still reflect cultural identity and influence how audiences understand the character.
ReplyDeleteI actually really liked this article/chapter of this book! The phenomena he is talking about here is really fascinating to me and I have discussed it in other courses. I personally really like part when he talked about how the culture does produce certain movies, but movies in turn shape the culture. The other course where I talked about this was Political Science Research Methods; we read a whole book on this! The example the book used was Harry Potter (which was dated) but the authors did a content analysis on the book. They then took the common themes and distributed a survey to see if college students who had read Harry Potter would be more likely to adhere to certain political stances rather than those who didn't. Those who read Harry Potter WERE found to generally be more empathetic, against using cruelty, and having anti-authoritarian tendencies. There's a lot of cool data in that book, and it shows that what we watch does play a part in political socialisation. I think this is exactly what he is getting at in this text. Individualism is a HUGE part of Western society, it makes sense that it shows up in our movies. Then, when younger generations see it themselves, it reroots itself into the zeitgeist.
ReplyDeleteI really struggled to find something to disagree with and I think this is because of the chapter's introductory nature; we’re not really into the meat of his writing and claims yet. This article is exciting though, as it arrives at the intersection of three of my major interests: film, education, and sociology! I found this part about a nuanced social world and films as modern-day folktales to be really thought provoking.
ReplyDelete“People must actively work to make sense of their lives and the complicated social world in which they live. They often must struggle with contradictory notions. I suggest that one way in which we collectively manage to cope with the complexity and confusion of social life is to package reality and to represent it as fiction—to tell stories about our social world that make it more comprehensible. In this sense, films can be viewed as modern-day cultural myths and folktales.”
In this way, Bulman is likening films—popculture to be our modern-day myths and folktales—folk culture, as Delaney was talking about in his chapter. Before I can fully agree, I’d have to explore what constitutes a folk tale. But I see what he’s saying. Films have become a way for us to reinterpret our reality just as religion/folklore/spoken tradition has been for so many people before us. Bulman also notes that films are not a reflection of reality but only a way we interpret our realities, which is important to note. In the future, we won’t be able to study films to see a memorialization of exactly how we lived and felt at this time, but rather we will see the way we responded to those conditions.
I truly could not find something to disagree about and I think this essay was beautifully written. What I did find interesting, though, was the passage about how movies are magic: "Movies are magic. They change things. They take the real and make it into something else right before your very eyes...They give the reimagined, reinvented, version of the real..." I agree with this statement and find it very compelling. Recently, I watched a movie with my best friend Finn called "Empire Records". It's a movie about a bunch of teenagers working at a record store, and all kinds of crazy antics happen. While I was watching this movie, I felt like I was transported into another world---I wanted to live in this movie, and it felt dreamlike, grand, and almost fairytale. This essay made me think on why I felt like that. How was this movie so compelling and interesting to the point where it felt dreamlike when, in reality, all the events that occured in this movie could very easily happen in real life? It's because truly, good movies do make real situations into magic. They transform the mundane into entire worlds, with soundtracks, artistry, and depth. This phenomenon is why I truly do adore movies; they make it easy for my imagination to enter another world.
ReplyDeleteI disagree with Bulman on stating that race is less important than social class. While he conducted his research, he only really focused on the social and class aspects of the films. He says that "a social class lens better explains the data," which, in my opinion, is not true. Race plays a big role in film. Films back then used the teacher savior trope a lot, and that relies on racial dynamics, an example being a white teacher "saving" the students of color.
ReplyDeleteHey Sage here! I disagree with Bulman's statement "For a text to be popular its message must fit the discourses used by the readers to make sense of their experience." I disagree with this statement because movies in a high school setting often make stereotypes that aren't even comparable to real life. For example, the typical "jock" bully stereotype, sure there may be some athletic males that can be bullies, but many from what I have seen don't shove kids into lockers or go out of their way to harm someone. People in high school usually keep to themselves rather than laying their hands on someone else today from my experience (I am not sure what it is like for others).
ReplyDelete"Films teach us who we are as much as they reflect who we are"
ReplyDeleteI relate to this quote a lot, I grew up watching a lot of movies, and I've learned so many things like lingo and social cues. I learned about peoples morals and what motivates them and integrated that into my life without knowing. Watching movies has also taught me to ask questions and do my own research about how things work and we why perceive things a certain way
I mostly agree with everything he said because he mainly just said what he was going to talk about and what he hopes to find from this exploration. However, I feel like one thing is I don’t think that it’s going to give the insight of people’s mind about adolescents as the author thinks it’s going to. I understand the chain of logic that he went through to arrive at this point. Hollywood is an entertainment industry, so in order to make the most amount of money, they try to appeal to the masses, pop culture. Therefore, these movies give insight to what people think about high school. “Yet films do reveal a certain truth … may not paint an accurate picture … tells us truths about the culture that produces and consumes them.” I just don’t think that it is going to reveal as much as he sets it up to do. This is because I followed the logical chain of: Hollywood is an entertainment industry, so in order to make the most amount of money, they try to appeal to the masses, pop culture, and therefore, let us know what is “cool” at the time. I think I would have to read more about the book and see more of the conclusions he draws before I can be certain, but I am skeptical to see if it really is going to show us something never seen before.
ReplyDeleteI disagree with the way Bulman discusses his classification system of social classes. He gives the classification system of: poor, middle class, and upper-middle class/rich. I also somewhat disagree with his "classification" system--he presents a stepping stone between "middle class" and "rich," referring to it as "upper-middle class," but offers no such bridge between "poor" and "middle class." I wonder why that is. Bulman also conflates "poor" with "urban," and "middle class" with "suburban," which I personally find unsatisfactory and simple, and possibly a little problematic. What is *urban* anyway? Because I'm sure a movie that depicts middle-class students going to a well-off school in New York City would be a film set in an "urban" environment--but I get the feeling that's not what Bulman means by "urban." Why does living in cities (an urban environment) equate to a lower-class lifestyle, and living in the suburbs is conflated with a more wealthy lifestyle? I don't know what cities Bulman is living in, but in my experience, it's often *more expensive* to rent or own in the city. I also don't appreciate how Bulman uses "poor" and "working class" interchangeably, as if people in the middle to rich classes are not working.
ReplyDeleteI know that this vocabulary is not unique to Bulman, but it is something that bothers me. I wonder if there are better ways to discuss socioeconomic status? I wonder how Bulman would possibly change the categorization of his paper if he were to write it today. I feel there must be more sensitive ways to talk about social classes than "urban" or "working class," phrases that always feel as if they are talking down to a group of people.
Forgot to say but this is Josephine btw!
DeleteWhile reading Bulman's chapter, I found myself disagreeing with a specific point he made stating that films reflect culture. I believe that films often romanticize or in other words make things appear better than they appear. Films such as High School Musical or Lemonade Mouth usually depict american schools completely different than what they actually are.
ReplyDeleteAlex T. here!
ReplyDeleteMy disagreement is very technical, because it doesn't go against a thought or quote actually mentioned in the chapter. It's going against an impression I got reading it, and is more-so critiquing what I felt was neglected, regarding " ...my analysis of the high school films that a social class lens than a lens of race," and Hollywood films about education pre-college being a reflection/causation of popular culture overall.
It's very hard to ignore that high school movies about being a POC (and for my argument, specifically being Black), or just with a main character who is a POC exist- but these films very rarely are able to be released, or get treated, as Hollywood hits. American pop culture and Black American pop culture sometimes have to be respected as their own things (even with a lot of what we consider "American" culture being from Black Americans, but for this argument I will separate them), because what media speaks to and shapes the Black community's idea of education (usually ending up as cult classics between us, at least for the older generation) is, I'm sure, very different than the media Bulman chose, which he specifically justified as fitting his economic-class list versus racial demographic.
I understand this was published in 2005, and there's a lot more chapters/explanations to come from the 7 pages I have access to at this moment, however movies like Cooley High, Love Don't Cost a Thing, House Party, Love and Basketball, Remember the Titans, and a ton more fit Bulman's descriptions of the 'High School Movie trope,' were released during the time he started his search, and touch on all classes & hierarchies/cliques within education. These movies are very hard to separate from being Black, nor would I give them the title of Hollywood hits or the freshest of Rotten Tomatoes, but their impact still stands just like the (assumed NONE of these made the cut) other 177 films in his sample. They aren't necessarily ABOUT being Black either, but maybe the community they impacted is considered too narrow, the stories too separated from the masses. Nevertheless, I say this all to say I'd be very concerned if Bulman's list has a shockingly low percentage of POC-centered (with or without the plot being about race) stories, while he actively chose to ignore that avenue.
One idea from Bulman’s first chapter that I disagreed with was the idea that culture from movies has a major influence on the way people understand the world around them. I do not believe that movies and entertainment can affect people's opinion, but I do think people still have the ability to think for themselves and create their own ideas and beliefs.
ReplyDeleteJaedan Baron
DeleteI couldn't find anything to disagree with so I found something to agree with. I agree with his ideas that "Movies make magic.They change things. They take the real and make it something else right before your eyes" which I full heartedly agree. a great example of this is Tyler perry's Movie Diary of a Mad Black Women where the main character is portrayed as the tile suggest a mad Black women. which plays into this idea that Black women are these aggressive and angry people. which can be said about anyone, but because it was put into a movie and shown that now its the normal for women to Angry and aggressive.
ReplyDeleteIzaiyah waters
DeleteWhile reading Bulman Chapter 1, I found myself agreeing with most things mentioned, however I have one critique about the ongoing theme in the reading. Bulman mentions multiple times that film is a reflection of society and culture, I do agree with these to an extent however I believe that films often exaggerate and romanticize many storylines that end up making it unrealistic and not an accurate view into those societies and cultures. For example, the movie Breakfast Club is a very popular high school movie, however I think realistically if a bunch of kids had to spend Saturday detention together it would most likely not end up in a trauma bonding circle, makeout sessions, and they are all friends afterwards. Overall I would say that film can be a reflection of society and culture but not an accurate one.
ReplyDeleteNothing stood out to me that I disagreed with, but I really liked how he explained that sometimes for a film, book or TV show to be "relatable" to the viewers that it displays certain stereotypes or scenarios to help the viewers "make sense of their experience." Although most of these stereotypes (jock, mean girl, etc) may not be seen as much in real life, bullying years ago was different, and more violent (according to older family members i've talked to.) So for this group of people, the films may still make sense to them. -Hannah Steeley
ReplyDeleteThe main thing I disagreed with in Bulman's reading is about the movie statement about how films can tell me truths about societies because most of the time movies over exaggerate a lot of things. I totally get that movies can show us a lot of pop culture norms that makes us watch them which is very common in this time. The reason I disagree with this is because films can give people false idea about how society is like in the real world. I am really into films and TV shows, so I understand if a director is trying to give us a deeper message in their films and I would only assume that you really have to pay attention to try and find it. For the average film buff would probably see it very quickly but for someone who is trying to watch a movie, it could mean nothing to them and they can just take what they've seen in the movie into their lives, which could be wrong, misunderstood, or exaggerated information.
ReplyDeleteThis is Brendan Patac
DeleteI agree with the majority of his points. One thing I kinda disagree with in the reading is the idea that movies are mainly a reflection of what society thinks about people and the world around them. I believe movies are primarily made to create conversation and entertainment. I agree that a lot of representation, like high school dramas for instance, can be based on real experiences. However, I do not think these stories are made because it’s what society believes to be true. It’s usually simply a way to draw attention and cash grab unfortunately, especially in Hollywood. I believe as time goes on we are seeing a lot more effort in films maybe being bias because a many Gen Z directors made great films this year but I genuinely believe if we look in to this conversation more we could have better representation as a whole, but we still have a ton of work to do.
ReplyDeleteThis is Danielle
DeleteOne thing I disagreed with in Bulman Chapter 1 was the idea that someone's success comes from within themselves regardless of their situation. I understand what he means because someone does have to put in effort to make their own choices but I don't think success is only based on the individual. The people around you and the opportunities you are given can also have a big effect on how successful you are. Someone could be working really hard in school, but they still struggle just because they don't have the same resources or support as the other students. I think high school movies can make it seem like someone can overcome anything as long as they work hard enough or believe in themselves, but I just don't think that's always realistic.
ReplyDelete