Postman has some interesting ideas about what kinds of skills we need to learn in school. Looking back, do you think you were ever taught how to “crap detect”? If so, describe the learning experience. If not, why do you think you were never taught to do this?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
August 20…Popculture
Was Delaney’s definition of popculture new to you? Comment on your relationship with popculture. Have you been able to find ways to bring an...
-
Was Delaney’s definition of popculture new to you? Comment on your relationship with popculture. Have you been able to find ways to bring an...
-
Find something (an idea, a claim, an argument, etc.) in Bulman Ch 1 to disagree with. Explain what it is and shy you disagree with it. N...
-
What other classes have you had in which individualism was discussed? How was it talked about? Is it seen largely as a good thing or a bad t...
Looking back, I think I was taught how to “crap detect,” but very vaguely. My learning experience came from an IB English teacher I had for two years in high school. The funny thing is, I could tell she was a BS teacher too, in the sense that, yes, I learned a lot from her, but a lot of it came from my own self-discovery and intellect while doing her “busy” work.
ReplyDeleteWhen we were preparing to take our IB exams, we were running super behind in class. Because of this, we had to quickly get through the smaller assigned readings that all IB juniors and seniors were required to do. We would basically BS through those readings so that we could move on to the actual IB material and build off of it. She actually taught us how to do this because she explained that when she was an English major in school, all she did was read and write reports, so she had to get really good at getting through readings efficiently.
Looking back, I realize that this was probably how I was taught to “crap detect.” I learned how to recognize what information was actually important, what I could skim over, and how to get the main idea without spending unnecessary time on every single detail. It was not something that was directly taught to me as a specific skill, but rather something I developed through experience and necessity.
I think I was often taught how to crap detect from a very early age. I believe so, due to my parents background in federal government. Both of them work full time, and it's been their careers from 20+ years. My learning experience however, reflected the similar things I was taught by my parents. For example, my senior year english teacher often had us do assignments that worked toward finding reliable sourcing that wasn't biased nor unreliable.
ReplyDeleteTo look at my parents for an example of how to "crap detect", me and my dad often get into conversation that we both fundamentally disagree on. Often times to prove to him that I was "right" I would use my knowledge from my major. He would say some sort of generalized thing, and in return, I would smack him with evidence from my own education--which usually gets him to smile and reflect on his initial points.
Meanwhile, my teacher in english always required us to actually read what we were researching. Skimming led to many situations in which my research wasn't as well developed- as sometimes my point could be disproven in my own research findings. She taught my class how to ensure we were getting to the actual core of our topics. I believe both of these examples changed exactly how I learned how to crap detect. As it wasn't a skill I necessarily was aware of, until reflecting on it currently.
In agreeance with Angel, I do feel as though I may have been taught to "crap detect," but it was very vague. Personally, I believe I wasn't taught to crap-detect extensively was because of how I go to school in a time where technology is the main resource for everything. Especially now since A.I. is so prominent, I have had teachers in the past specifically instruct us to "just use A.I" to answer my questions.
ReplyDeleteLast year, one of my favorite teachers of all time, my senior year DE English teacher Ms. Cupps would take some of my written essays and put them into ChatGPT and prompt them to "edit my essays." She would tell me to take the advice and let the computer do all the work for me (and yes, even though she did this, she is still one of my favorite teachers ever---she truly was a great educator besides the A.I. usage).
Before my senior year---when I wasn't quite educated on the harmfulness of A.I.---I did fall victim to using it for some assignments. I believe this is where my lack of crap-detecting came from. From then on, I had to learn to crap-detect entirely by myself.
Being an English major, a lot of my life has become sorting out what is BS and what is not. The cliches, the big words, Eichmannism, bigotry, you name it, some author wrote it. When I read the Bell Jar by Sylvia Plath, I was doing a lot of crap-detecting by trying to ignore all the bullshit sporadic racism (an example of bigotry, like Postman said) that is included in the book. Most of it was not even necessary, and it taught me that not every part of a renown book is going to be ground-breaking.
Looking back, I would say that I was taught to “crap-detect”. I wouldn’t say there is any class in particular that taught this important skill, just something that was taught gradually over time in multiple classes. I would do different assignments that would require me to think more critically about what I am reading and researching. I had to do more deep diving and research to get the proper information. There are many unreliable sources out there, so I was taught how to search for the most reliable sources on the internet, typically ones sourced from local news, or government websites.
ReplyDeleteI feel as though I was taught crap-detection pretty early on. Coming from Australian Immigrant parents, I went into school with a fairly high degree of skepticism surrounding the patriotism instilled in us at the elementary level. I remember being sent to the administrative office in 1st grade when substituting "God" in the pledge of allegiance with "dog." Since I'd learned about America's foundation as a country with freedom of religion, I figured that the pledge should better represent us as individual citizens (and I happened to really like dogs). Similarly, I went into 4th grade history with prerequisite knowledge surrounding genocide and oppression amongst the pilgrims and Native Americans, leading me to writing much more opinionated statements in my Virginian history homework.
ReplyDeleteLater down the line, I think crap-detection was mostly introduced academically in middle school, as we had started dipping our toes into scholarly sources and writing research essays. My first introduction to this in school was the craze surrounding Wikipedia. Likewise to how Postman introduces the concept of superstition and inanity, we were influenced to assume that any source that could be edited by the general public could contain uneducated and subjective perspectives, often containing no factual or scientific basis. As this developed later in school to consider sources with more academic value, we started ruling out most pieces of writing lacking a reputable author or peer review, even if the article itself was from a direct author. This is important because it made a distinction that any article writer could be part of the general public we were so weary of previously. My biggest reality check here was when I was writing a literature review in 10th grade, not paying too much attention to the merit of the sources I was using. It wasn't until my advisor asked me to back up the statistics I was providing that I realized my entire research question was driven by a statistic coming from an article by an advertising organization that was attempting to promote their product through unsuspecting articles loaded with faulty facts and statistics. Since this, I've learned to not only be careful about the validity of the source itself, but also to run a quick background check on the author to verify that they're not writing under a sponsor or ulterior motive.
I actually think I was taught to crap-detect at school or at least a very basic version of it. When I was growing up was the time educators really started to emphasize the importance of staying skeptical when reading posts on the internet. Teachers understood that our main news source was social media, and they warned us against it. However, I still do think I can fall susceptible to a lot of crap. I have recently discovered that when presented with a fact deriving from research on the internet, I don't even bat an eye. Even though as a writer it has been drilled in me to choose reliable sources, I did not even consider that when reading. This makes me more nervous reading stuff online for sure. I definitely wish schools emphasized more skepticism and how to figure out if a source is actually credible or not.
ReplyDelete.
ReplyDeleteThis is Alex!
ReplyDeleteI'd say I was taught pretty heavily against "crap detecting" in school actually, and my explanation + experience comes from being an autistic child who did not understand social cues.
I very frequently questioned rules, lessons, even sentences/instructions that other people would just, "get," because I take things literally and generally need to have a justification for why things are just done a certain way. People very frequently heard things I didn't say, and if I combatted that it suddenly wasn't okay for ME to view THEM as incompetent. This got me called very rude, argumentative, blunt, etc. as a kid ("You'd be a good lawyer one day," which I only now understand was condescending a lot of - but not all of- the time) if I challenged any topic- this mostly got me in trouble during religious, political, or historical discussions, that I personally felt was... bullshit, as the theme of this piece is. This includes academic/scholarly media, field trips, socratic seminars, everything that could have happened in school or church. [Superstition & Fanaticism]
Depending on the specific context, I think these three topics are pretty heavily debated about being appropriate for children to be exposed to via a curriculum. Kids are quite underestimated in having their own autonomy- they're great at mimicking, but they're also great at questioning the world around them, the mimicry usually comes back when they are told that the questioning is unreliable or disrespectful, and "that's just the way things are." In other words, shut down (This doesn't do justice to scenarios where the mimicry does need to be intervened, however, kids can bandwagon on things like bullying and dangerous behavior). I understand a lot of people want there to be a distinct line between what is taught from educators and what is taught by family, but if the worst thing to happen to a kid and their peers in school is learning to "crap detect," maybe people have to deconstruct their own ideas about what they means and what they may have accepted throughout their life.
As an adult, I relish the thought of laying down in bed and watching nonsense commentary YouTube videos or TikTok's on whatever subject catches my eye, but I also know I have to accept that they're just strangers with a camera and microphone who I may like the voice and humor of a bit more than others. Postman's point on inanity is funny to me, because it's a pretty common joke that podcast's and their hosts are going to be the death of us. These people do not automatically deserve to hold more weight in conversations because they talk in mics and invite guests to degrade every now and then. Anybody can do it, which is why it is either totally harmless or just a disaster.
After reading the reading I believed that I was never directly taught this idea of crap detection, please excuse my language. However I do think that they have tried telling me to avoid the nonsense when it comes to reading and writing. A lot of the time it would come across as just ways to save time, or some tips to not waste brain power on what’s not important, which is pretty much what crap detection is. It would usually be small things to help avoid the clutter but since it eventually became common knowledge the older I got, it never became apparent to me how impactful of a skill it was to have and use in my day to day life.
ReplyDeleteLooking back I can’t say I was taught to “crap-detect”. I am reminded of our lessons in media literacy, which felt a bit like crap detection, but not fully. Teachers always had to be very careful to remain apolitical in their teachings, and it often felt like they were filtering their words through the voices of parents in their heads. Parents who take issue with everything taught in schools and believe themselves to be in control of the curriculum. We had a lot of issues with book-banning in Hanover county, and that always felt like a bunch of crap that we were all simultaneously detecting but couldn’t do anything about.
ReplyDeleteBeing taught to crap detect creates more autonomous, independent thinkers. I don’t think that was my schools #1 priority. If you teach a student to crap detect, maybe they'll be more likely to call the school on their crap. I really enjoyed this article, and the messaging behind it. I liked when he called religion and patriotism bullshit. I’d really like to explore this idea of crap detecting more. And how it could fit in with “critical thinking” that is so heavily discussed right now. I think they are getting at the same idea; we engage too passively with our surroundings and let ideas penetrate us without giving them real fleshed-out thought; if we start giving real consideration to the things we read, see, and hear then we will be more able to depend ourselves against all of the crap pushed onto us every day.
In my English class in high school we were taught about how to identify biases and which publications tend to lean left/right/center, and the dangers of only getting our information from one source. I do feel that teachers often discussed "fake news" and biases as if they were very easy to detect, or as if news articles that spread misinformation had a "fake news" warning. We also never talked about social media and how that is one of the biggest sources of fake news and misinformation, and the dangers of rabbit holes or pipelines.
ReplyDeleteI believe that in school we were never taught to “detect crap”, however, I was taught outside of school. Looking back, my mom always raised me to kind of look at everything from a certain perspective. It’s brought me to the point where I can “detect” certain crap that happens in the world. I liked the comment he made about “each person’s crap-detector is embedded in their value system.” I found this part interesting because I feel that Postman was saying that, depending on who you are as an individual, it can determine whether or not your crap detector can work better than others. Schools teach most children certain sets of rules, and because we are taught about these rules that basically makes us almost robotic. Making it harder for children in schools to kind of have a mind of their own. When growing up, a lot of these rules and regulations schools put in place make things harder for students to voice or think of their opinion. I believe because of this, it’s harder for “crap” to be detected throughout school systems.
ReplyDeleteI don't remember ever sitting through a "crap detecting" lesson in school or being taught by my parents, but I think I learned how to do it myself by dismissing false statements I would read or hear someone say based on my knowledge on the topic; like if someone confidently stated that 2+2=7, I would say "no, that's not true, you're wrong". I also just like to know and learn about things as well as correct people, (I used to do it a lot when I was younger, but I'm getting better) but I just want everyone to know the facts of things and avoid spreading misinformation.
ReplyDeleteI think throughout high school I was taught the basics like everyone else. Such as how to find a reliable source, what bias/unbiased articles look like, and how to look out for what an opinion is vs a fact. But I do find the argument of Postman’s Fourth Law to be very interesting. I also agree with the fact the simple human conversations can be and usually do have more in-depth hidden meanings that never come to light. And school may have taught us how to distinguish between articles in order to produce papers, but it hasn’t prepared us on having to distinguish between bullshit in everyday conversations and interactions.
ReplyDeleteLooking back at my childhood, I believe i was taught it indirectly. I think from some of my old classes and just growing up with the internet I was able to form my own "crap detection" technique. A lot of my english classes stated for us to not get all our information/citations from one single source and to broaden our information.
ReplyDeleteThis is JAEDAN BARON!
ReplyDeleteLooking back to my years in grade school I think I was taught somewhat directly to "crap detect". I think as I've grown up and become the student I am today I've slowly realized and learned what bs is and when it is detected. In high school, I wrote many essays and papers and most of my teachers would emphasize on getting straight to the point instead of using filler words and phrases to make a paragraph long or make a essay look longer. Now that I've gotten to college it seems that I do have to now add that bs to a lot of papers just to meet the requirements of needing and essay to be 3-8 pages long, which completely goes against what I've been taught. But as generations continue to grow in technology and social media it is now harder but also kind of easier to detect bs and crap on social media and political statements/problems now.
I feel like I was taught, but it was done in an indirect way. For example, in science class they kept saying to make sure the sources I used were good. Actually, really thinking back on it, I wasn’t really taught at all. I am just remembering in math class there were so many times that a concept was explained just enough to be able to replicate on a test, but there was no learning. There were never questions about why. I found a similar situation in science too. The only reason I built a bullshit detector was because I was initially curious about the topic, so I asked the questions why and tried to figure out if something was bullshit or not.
ReplyDeleteI don't ever remember being taught how to detect "crap" in school, but I do know that it's a skill I developed on my own through many years of school, teachers, and classes. This skill isn't only useful for academic scenarios, I have also used it in my daily life. Sometimes people can hide their intentions so it's important to be able to determine if your time is being wasted.
ReplyDelete-Hannah
DeleteLooking back I do have to say I was taught how to "crap detect," but usually from my English teachers. They usually lecture to the class about how to detect "crap" sources for our papers and essays. However, for media I would say I did develop my own kind of crap detection. What is considered crap to me may be a piece of treasure for others. I am very particular on what kind of media I'd like to consume and watch. There is definitely crap/bullshit that is considered crap/bullshit to others, but to me holds a special place in my heart.
ReplyDeleteI think I was able to "crap detect" in school, but I never really thought of it that way. I was taught to question things instead of just believing everything I read or heard. For example, when doing something like research, I learned to look at where the information came from, whether the source was reliable, and whether or not there was actual evidence to back it up. I think that connects to what Postman means by crap detecting. At the same time, I don't think I was taught as much about questioning my own opinions or biases. I was taught to focus more on figuring out if someone was giving bad information. I think learning to recognize your own "bullshit" is something that comes more from experience and actually being willing to question yourself.
ReplyDeleteThroughout school, I feel as though I was taught how to “crap detect” indirectly, through learning how to identify valid sources of journalism, peer-reviewed articles, primary vs. secondary sources, etc. These are all technical skills that obviously serve students well in middle/high school, but they’re also applicable and transferable to many different areas of study as people pursue higher education. Through this, “crap detecting” skills show through by learning to appreciate and seek out other people’s perspectives on different topics, not just in academia, but also in noticing trends on social media, to avoid believing and spreading misinformation.
ReplyDeleteI learned to "crap detect" from my teachers in high school. Not directly though, when a student whose grades were bad and got a really good score out of nowhere the crap detector goes off. Or when a student is repeatedly going yo the bathroom at the same time everyday, they're definitely up to no good which would set off the crap detector.
ReplyDeleteIzaiyah waters
DeleteI would say that I learned how to “crap detect” from my mom, not my school. During my freshmen and sophomore year of high school I was in a special program at my school where we mainly focused on English, history, philosophy, and art history topics. A lot of the students and teachers in the program prioritized using very big fancy words, and having your writing be very dense. I remember that I felt like I could write and get my point across without writing pages and pages of nonsense like my fellow peers, and I also did not understand the point of writing way more than you needed to because at that point you were just bullshitting to impress the teacher. Also due to my dyslexia I would often have grammar or spelling mistakes, and I did not understand using big fancy words either in your writing especially if the average person often did not understand them or know what they meant. Due to my differences compared to my peers with the way I would write, I would often receive lower grades even if I stated the same points that my peers made (I also remember that I would receive the lower grades due to not writing over the word count and not using big fancy words which my teachers would point out to me with their grading notes). I would complain to my mom about these occurrences and she taught me that the way the program was set up favored a very specific way of writing essays, and that way just did not align with my way of thinking. She also helped me understand that the dense writing of my peers was mainly just to impress people, however it does not appeal to the average person especially if they just want you to get to the point. My mom showed me that some people’s writing just has a lot of unnecessary wording and sentences to try to show off.
ReplyDeleteI would say that I was taught how to "crap detect" but more so indirectly. I remember being taught to think critically and to not believe everything that I read or hear about. To have the skill to fact check things and not blindly believe everything is true just because it was on the internet or someone who seems knowledgeable about the topic says it's true.
ReplyDeleteThroughout my schooling growing up I believe I was definitely taught how to crap detect, but the experiences I remember of it were mostly focused around technology and the internet. I remember taking computer lab, english classes, and librarian lessons in elementary and middle school where they taught us how to find actual good sources online, to not believe everything we see on the internet, and good researching techniques. I think the reason the crap-detection from my schooling revolved mainly around the internet and technology was because these were new tools that were introduced into the classroom. My generation was the first to experience what it's like to have a technology filled classroom as young as kindergarten, so I think there were lots of skills and "crap-detection" that needed to be taught, considering the internet is filled with tons of crap.
ReplyDeleteThe way i've seen "crap detect" was through a lot of my research classes, specifically the one I had last semester. Even though my teachers in the past didn't use the term "crap detect," in my research methods class, my professor would always tell us to make sure we know where our information came from and not automatically believe information is correct. We always had to make sure our sources we used was reliable and to compare our information to other sources to make sure they match up. It really helped me in the end because for my final research paper in that class, I kept going back and forth through sources checking if everything was correct. Doing all of that made me master all of the information for my project and once I kept spamming source checking, it became very fast and easy.
ReplyDeleteThis is Brendan Patac
DeleteWhen I look back at it, I don't think I was ever taught how to crap detect. However I think as you experience different scenarios you learn that not all information is correct even if it's through a trusted source. Sometimes you figure out that things in the moment feel unfair and you detect why. But overall, I don't think I was taught this because for most people it comes with common sense and it doesn't really come to your attention that you need to teach others this mainly because most people already do it.
ReplyDeleteI wouldn’t say I was necessarily taught to “crap detect” I’ve just always naturally asked questions and I guess came from a family who would teach me not to trust everybody. I feel that asking questions and knowing your sources is a great way to communicate and learn instead of potentially not knowing and risking the chance of spreading misinformation or getting easily manipulated. -Danielle
ReplyDeleteI dont think I was ever taught to crap detect as a kid. Sure, my parents had always told me to be aware and really pay attention to what people say. But I learned that through myself. Both of my parents served in the Air Force so I moved a bunch as a kid. I was able to meet many people and their different lifestyles and behaviors
ReplyDeleteWith school, I remember always needing to pay extra attention to my sources because I would always want to choose the first few links and be done with it. Even. when they weren't very reliable
I think the earliest experiences I've had with being taught about crap detecting in school was around 6th Grade. In my social studies class we would have to write weekly reports on news around the world or sometimes on US news. The teacher would warn us about and show us how to spot bias in articles or reports. They were very strict about wikipedia and would fail the assignment if we were ever caught using it. He actually said that before essays or anything that required writing and research, he would go into wiki's that were about the topic to put false things in there to try and slip students up.
ReplyDeleteI was definitely taught how to crap detect back in school as well as in home. We were always taught about how bias was always something to look for in articles. This also goes for in person crap detecting like telling if someone has not the greatest intentions which usually is something you learn through experiences. - Ximena
ReplyDeleteLooking back, I think I was taught how to “crap detect” but I don't think it was something that was specifically taught to me. I remember teachers telling us that just because someone says something confidently or a lot of people believe in it doesn't just mean it's true. I think I learned this more as I got older because I started seeing it on social media. Someone can post something and thousands of people will comment and repost it without even knowing if its true. I have seen a lot of things online that, at first glance, I could believe are true but when I actually look into it, I see that they’re not. I think school did help me learn to question things more and not just believe what everyone else does.
ReplyDeleteLooking back, I remember being taught how to "crap detect" to various degrees. Checking the credibility on sources, the warning against misinformation (especially surrounding election time), were all parts of a conversation I was lucky enough to be involved in. I remember having some kind of acronym describing steps to "feel out" the credibility of something but its evading me right now. These were lessons I remember being taught in classes of mine, English I think. However to switch the lense, growing up with three older brothers who took the "it says gullible on the ceiling" joke and never truly let it go, I learned to fact check early. -Marielle Sadlowski
ReplyDelete