Tuesday, August 18, 2026

October 8…Bulman Revisited

Think back to Bulman’s ideas about Hollywood and high school. If possible, share something that you think he got right and also provide critique of some aspect of his ideas. 

26 comments:

  1. With the perspective of all three movie lists, as well as the sitcom episodes we've watched in class, I believe that Bulman definitely offered a solid analysis on the correlation between class and agency, given that most of the movies depicting lower class students fell into a savior trope with the teacher. I do believe the more recent these movies get, however, the agency tends to highlight experiences from disparaged groups (such as students in lower socioeconomic classes), as the trend has been gearing towards empowerment of those students instead of just trying to make a feel-good plot about them being "saved." I think this shows up in the last movie I personally watched (being Lady Bird) as it focuses on the coming of age and development of agency with a poor (albeit white) girl, and even includes the plots of her seeking financial aid, her father losing his job when they're already poor, tethering a lot of her life experiences and even shame overlapping to her financial situation. Upon watching Moxie, the major theme was already on feminism, and amongst that giving light to children of immigrants, women of color, lesbians, and victims of violent sex crimes. Of course, these don't have as much to do with socioeconomic class, but Bulman's conflation of race and class bring up a good perspective about it. Given that the second edition of this book was published in 2015, I think that Bulman could have foreseen the direction of these dynamics of agency, so that even if he couldn't have represented the variable of race effectively, he at least would have talked about the rising outliers from this formula (as in many modern movies usually have characteristics that don't just give agency to higher-class students. This could potentially go hand in hand with the trend of movies where the protagonist must overcome their "poor" status to achieve their goals, which I'm sure has some increasing overlap with high school movies.

    ReplyDelete
  2. When revisiting Bulman, I can see how his mind was working when analyzing the films he saw. In my case, I can agree with his analysis somewhat. The concept of a savior trope with teachers being alleviated with agency from students is accurate, even when we look at films as recent as 2023 (The Holdovers). Obviously, he's correct on his point on how films only have about 2 hours to constrain complicated relationships, thereby, simplifying them. We can see this in Clueless. She has no deep relation with any of the girls she's supposedly "friends with", or at least, it's not show. However, something I want to critique with Bulman's lack of association with race and the savior complex tied to it throughout movies. His critique is on social class, but he doesn't seem to acknowledge the racial dynamics associated within middle-class culture. It positions black and brown students as inept and unable to help themselves without a white teacher to validate and help them. I think additionally, he believes that viewers need to be spoon-fed information and storylines, most people are more critical of films than he believes. Especially in circumstances where the film may be relatable of their lives or current experiences.

    ReplyDelete
  3. When thinking back to Bulman’s Chapter 1, he talked about how Hollywood can manipulate reality to make situations more dramatic or add some kind of comic relief, especially because films are made to be commercially successful. I can agree with this because I think we have seen it in many films, like Lady Bird when Lady Bird jumps out of the moving car, or Vivian in Moxie having awkward moments with the guy she likes. I think Bulman got the comic relief part right, and I agree that some situations are made more dramatic for entertainment. However, I would critique the idea that the dramatic moments in films are always unrealistic. Sometimes real life really can be that dramatic. For me, when I was in high school, I would sometimes feel like something was the end of the world, even if it was not actually that serious. So, I think some of the drama shown in high school films can actually reflect how students may feel in real life. This includes the sad narratives in Freedom Writers, that did and still do happen to this day.

    Bulman also discusses individualism when looking at high school and film media. He explains that in order for characters to have autonomy, individualism is important to bring into films. I think this is true because we can see it through characters like Vivian in Moxie. Vivian created Moxie because she wanted to stand up for what she believed in and support feminism alongside her peers at school. This came from her own personal beliefs, but she also had to fight within herself to even allow herself to take that step. I think this shows individualism because Vivian was able to make her own choice and use her voice to create change instead of simply going along with what everyone else was doing.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thinking back to Bulman’s ideas he talked about connection between teacher and agency. While watching Stand and Deliver I saw that connection. Jaime Escalante was determine to teach his students Calculus which hasn't been done before at the school and for them to all pass the AP Calculus exam. Bulman also talked about individualism which I saw while watching Ferris Bueller's Day Off. The movie was about Ferris, Cameron, and Sloane adventure throughout Chicago while skipping school. Throughout the movie you can see the individualism difference between Ferris and Cameron.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Looking back at Bulman’s Chapter 1, I can see how Hollywood changes the way reality is shown to make movies more entertaining and interesting to audiences. He talks about how filmmakers might exaggerate conflicts, make certain situations more dramatic, or add comic relief because movies are made to attract viewers and make money. Bulman also talks about individualism in high school media and how students are often shown as people who have to overcome challenges, stand out, and figure things out for themselves. I agree with Bulman that high school movies sometimes exaggerate situations to make them more entertaining, but I don’t think that means all of the dramatic moments are exaggerated. Students can go through situations that feel extremely serious to them, even if they might not seem like a big deal to someone else. I remember being in high school and having certain problems feel way bigger and more overwhelming than they actually were. Because of this, I think some high school movies can realistically show how students experience their emotions and everyday struggles. At the same time, the focus on individualism can make it seem like students are supposed to handle everything on their own. In reality, what students go through is also affected by their friends, family, school environment, and the situations happening around them.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think Bulman gets it right when he says that Hollywood movies about high school can reflect what people think high school is supposed to be like. Movies often show certain stereotypes about students, teachers, popularity, cliques, and what it means to be “successful” in high school. I think these movies can shape people’s expectations, especially when they have not experienced high school yet. However, I think Bulman puts too much focus on movies shaping how people understand high school. A lot of high school movies are exaggerated for entertainment, so I don’t think most people actually believe that real high school is exactly like what they see in movies. From my own experience, high school was much more normal and less dramatic than how movies make it seem. I also think students’ real experiences, families, schools, friends, and social media can have just as much, if not more, influence on how they view high school. Overall, I agree that Hollywood can influence how people think about high school, but I don’t think it is the only or biggest influence on students’ ideas about it.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Mikayla Blackman-JonesOctober 7, 2026 at 8:13 PM

    Looking back at Bulman’s ideas about Hollywood and high school I believe Bulman is right about Hollywood presenting high school students and the environment does not reflect how things are in reality. Most movies and TV shows like to over exaggerate high school stereotypes like popularity, and romantic relationships to make the movie seem more entertaining and to build more tension to the plot. However this is not always true like in movies like Mean Girls and Clueless kind of turn teenage drama into something it's not. That high schoolers tend to go overboard in certain situations. I also believe that these stereotypes and social issues influence how people understand high school, which was another point from Bulman. I feel like because of movies that are set in a high school setting, it influences especially younger children on how they see high school.

    Looking at one limitation of Bulman ideas is that they don't equally represent different racial backgrounds. Lots of movies and TV shows usually focus on predominantly white schools or settings. I feel that Hollywood movies don’t get to explore the experience of other races like Black, Latino, etc., and other students of different backgrounds in general. Since this is the case the usual “American high school experience" that's depicted through the media is not always relatable to other people. Sometimes there are limits to the typical high school experience shown on TV, and Bulam perhaps could have focused more on how race can affect the way certain students experience high school.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I think Bulman makes a good point about how Hollywood uses high school settings to push different stereotypes. He shows that “urban” schools get framed as chaotic or underfunded, while “suburban” schools are more lesson-based. But one thing Bulman doesn’t fully capture is how race shapes these portrayals just as much as class. In many school shows, race influences who gets centered and how characters are allowed to grow. Bulman mentions race but doesn't go into it in much depth as he should've. I also think his focus on traditional films leaves out how animated shows use school differently. An example would be The Amazing World of Gumball doesn’t follow the usual “school as social hierarchy” trope. Instead, it uses the school as a playful and chaotic space that still reflects real ideas and learning.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I think Bulman is correct in his idea that students with lower socioeconomic status typically have less agency--often shows/movies with poorer students tend to depict the stereotype of the "hero teacher." All of the movies in the "hero teacher" trope take place in poorer schools with "at risk" students. Crucially, race is a large factor--or at least acknowledged--in all of those movies. This is something that Bulman never discusses. It is also true that in most of the movies where students have agency/are the main focus of the movie, the students tend to be wealthier. I do agree with Bulman's assertion that individualism is the uniting ideology behind all of these films. I think we all agree that Bulman is correct in his generalizations of how class/socioecenomic status is depicted in high school films, but feel that he ignores how race/racism is featured or talked about in these movies.

    ReplyDelete
  10. When revisiting bulman's ideas about Hollywood and High School, a few things stuck out to me; I liked when he said, "...which films resonate with a popular audience tell us much more about the reality of a particular society than the 'reality' of a film's subject." This is entirely true---while a film about a specific group of people/subject can be moving and accurate, the actual reaction to the film by that said group can actually be far more crucial, since it is the literal reality of that group. However, like we have discussed previously, I was not a huge fan of the fact that Bulman did not necessarily talk about the role of race and/or women in these films. Women and race discrimination can be big themes or even microaggressions that are seen throughout almost every movie created, and his ignorance to leave these important topics out surprised me and made me doubt his reputability. I wish that he could've gone into more depth with these topics, because race and womanly discrimination can sometimes go hand-in-hand with education-centered media.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I think Bulman was right when he talked about how socioeconomic class can affect the amount of agency students have in high school movies. A lot of movies about lower-income students focus on a teacher coming in and “saving” the students, while students from wealthier backgrounds are more likely to be shown having control over their own lives and making their own choices. I think this is something we can still see in movies today. However, I think one thing Bulman could have focused on more is race. A lot of the movies with the “hero teacher” trope also involve students from racial minority groups, so class and race can overlap in how these students are portrayed. I think leaving that out makes his analysis feel a little incomplete because students’ experiences in high school are influenced by more than just their socioeconomic status.

    ReplyDelete
  12. After watching the movies I feel like I agree with his take on how high school movies tend to overly simplify the idea of high school. This is especially true in comedy movies such as School of Rock since the point of the high school setting isn’t supposed to be a 1 to 1 depiction of high school. In comedies a lot of themes tend to be overlooked, simplified, or even completely ignored from the film. Since a film is really meant to display a story, and said story sometimes needs to take some things away to keep the story interesting and consistent. Even in more serious movies like Freedom Writers themes were taken more seriously, but I feel like that one did a better depiction on how real high school students’ lives could be. It’s a little bit of an outlier is what I am trying to say. However, going back to Bulman’s ideas, I still agree with his idea on how high school movies tend to bring a lot of ideas and expectations into people’s heads, especially when they are just starting high school. They later realize that high school isn’t as rigid and stereotypical as they expected. It can be exhausting at times, since some people tend to wanna fit into boxes that they see in movies, while in reality that really shouldn’t be the case.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I think Bulman was right about how Hollywood portrays high school differently depending on social class. Because in movies about lower class students, the focus was usually on their struggles and how a teacher helped them succeed in school. Movies about middle and upper class students focus more on their personal lives and friendships. I think this is a good point Bulman made because Hollywood usually uses similar storylines depending on the students backgrounds. One thing I would critique about Bulman's argument is that social class doesn't always affect how much agency students have. Even students who come from lower income backgrounds can make their own decisions and take control of their futures. So I think Bulman makes a good argument about the patterns that happen in Hollywood movies but those patterns don't necessarily just apply to every movie or or all students in real life.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Bulman's say's that school are depicted differently weather they're "urban" public schools, "Suburban" public schools, and Private school. And I agree with his statement Take the movie Lean on me for example the Movie starts off in a predominantly White high school was clean and orderly. But shortly after the school is now predominantly Black high school now out of order and messy. Or take a look ate School of Rock which is a private school that kids parents pay thousands of dollars for them to attend its nice, clean, and orderly. Which plays into this idea that we associate certain groups of people Urban schools which is basically poor/working class, then you have suburban schools which is middle class, and lastly Private schools which is rich and upper class.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I think the movies I ended up watching kind of emphasized Bulman's points to the extreme. I watched: To Sir With Love; Ferris Bueller's Day Off; and Half-Nelson. To Sir With Love and Half-Nelson both definitely lean more towards teacher agency rather than it lying with the students. Despite the nuances that are present in both films, the surface level analysis that less wealthy students get less agency in their films. Ferris Bueller's Day Off is the complete opposite with students holding all the agency despite adults' best attempts at taking it away from them. Ferris Bueller is also upper middle class with a friend is undeniably wealthy. I think the criticisms we have discussed in class though still apply. His complete ignorance of race definitely does not do the potential analysis of these films justice. To Sir With Love and Half-Nelson do not play as a typical teacher/white saviour movie. To Sir With Love has a Black teacher teaching mostly white students. The white saviour trope does not play here at all. Half-Nelson does feel white saviour-y at times, but it is also featuring a drug addict who is deeply flawed as the teacher. It's not perfect, but it definitely makes his attempts at reaching through to his students feel a little more genuine. Bulman was definitely right overall, but I don't like the sweeping generalisations he makes. However, maybe I am just a little too attached to my films; I am being too particular about the details. I mean, if he's right then he's right.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Looking back on Bulman’s arguments, I think he was right about the classic “white teacher savior complex” in movies especially if the film is set in an area that is lower class. I especially say this example when watching the movie “Dangerous Minds” where they show a perfect example of a high school within a rougher area and a new white teacher comes in and “saves” them. Also Bulman is correct with how Hollywood often makes things more dramatic and exciting to pull more viewers in. “Dangerous Minds” shows this again when they overdramaticsized the background story of the teacher and the death of a student in the movie, whereas in the true story that the movie was based on no one died and the teacher had an interesting background already but they added in a few unnecessary extra storylines. My critique topwards Bulman’s arguments is the lack of talking about race, especially when it is tied to the classic savior complex that is shown in movies because oftentimes those same movies mention race/make race have at least something to do with the storyline.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I think Bulman is completly right that Hollywood movies often create unrealistic ideas about high school. A lot movies make high school seem more very dramatic, exciting, or just focused on popularity than it really is. When I think of this, movies will often show students being divided into clear groups like athletes, popular kids, and outsiders. I think this can influence how people expect high school to be. But I do think Bulman may focus too much on movies as shaping students’ views. Students also get their ideas about high school from their own friends, socials, and TV shows. Because not every student will believe that high school has to look like a crazy popular movie.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I think Bulman gets it right when he talks about how Hollywood portrays high school as a place where students are constantly trying to figure out their identity and where they fit in. A lot of high school movies focus on popularity, social groups, and stereotypes such as the popular student, the athlete, the nerd, or the outsider. I think these portrayals can reflect real experiences because many teenagers do worry about fitting in and being accepted by others.But, I think Bulmans ideas can be limited because Hollywood does not represent every student’s actual high school experience. Movies usually exaggerate drama and create stereotypes because they are meant to entertain an audience. Not every student cares about popularity or fits into one specific social group. Students can have very different experiences depending on their personality, culture, background, and school. Because of this, I think Bulman is right about some of the pressures that teenagers experience, but Hollywood’s version of high school should not be treated as a completely accurate picture of what high school is like for everyone.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I believe many of Bulmans ideals regarding high school and hollywood are presented in various main stream media films. In "Lady Bird", the main character Christine wants to create her own identity and leave her hometown. However, her families financial struggles limit what she can do. Bulman argues that Hollywood movies often show how social class affects students opportunities and ability to make their own choices, or more specifically their agency. Lady Bird's social class has a heavy influence on her confidence and sense of belonging, but she does challenge these limits by applying to colleges in New York and making decisions about her future. So yes, as Bulman argues students backgrounds influence their experiences and opportunities but this is not a limit set in stone. -Marielle Sadlowski

    ReplyDelete
  20. In Bullman's work that we read in class, I can both agree and disagree with some of his comments about high school and Hollywood. One agree I agree with is when he says, "Hollywood routinely twists and shapes reality to maximize dramatic or comic effect for commercial purposes." I agree with this because I think it explains where and why we see so many "corny" or "unrealistic" high school movies and shows like High School Musical, Girl Meets World, etc. They're taken out of reality to make them entertaining and funny. A remark from Bullman that I'd like to critique is his lack of mentioning race. He tends to focus on social classes a lot, and while those do play a huge part in the conversation of high school and Hollywood, I think incorporating race would deepen and expand his writing.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Something that Bulman talked about is how Hollywood used schools to depict things that the real world is going through, experiences of people and problems in our society. I agree with this because when watching freedom writers although it had a "white savior teacher", it really showed the struggle in society and poverty. It showed how diverse we are not only in a school setting but in the world as a whole. The one thing I don't like in Hollywood is the "white savior teacher". It kind of contradicts what Bulman stated because although there are some, Its really unrealistic in the shows and movies that we've watched in class.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Some things I think Bulman got correct is the explanation of the white savior trope. I also agree with what he said about how Hollywood movies are "relatable" to a certain extent. For example, the tropes such as the jock and cheerleader are what a lot of people experienced in high school. That being said, that's not the case for everyone. Some schools may have had different dynamics. -Hannah S

    ReplyDelete
  23. There is this one quote from the Bulman chapter that I agree with it states "adolescents in these films are expected to transcend the limitations of their communities." This stuck out to me because it is true in most of these school or high school films majority of the time the parents have high expectations of their children; for example, they would want their kids to have good grades, hang out with the right group, and go to a good college. The main theme between all the school films is essentially the adults in these kids life wanting them to succeed in life and be able to thrive in their future. These kids in the films are suppose to be different and basically transcend their parents expectations either in a good or bad way. For example, in mean girls Cady was originally the new girl in her class and climbed the ranks in her school. She eventually became a child her parents didn't quite recognize anymore because she became obsessed with boys and herself rather than what her parents are use to which would be a good student. My only criticism of Bulman is that he is basing it off of films that he has watched and not all films are alike. I think Dead Poets Society was honestly one of the films that felt different and realistic to a sense of that children and young adult do have suicidal idealizations because they feel trapped. This was the first film where it kind of hit me because Neil wanted to pursue theatre and the arts and his father wouldn't allow him leading him to his demise. I heavily related to that where compared to Mean Girls it just kind of felt like a funny film.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Alex Thompson here!

    Generally, I do still strongly believe Bulman’s work or list of typical patterns found in teen/young adult school films would have benefitted from allowing himself to “indulge” in the very obvious impacts of race with the films. He acknowledges the correlation, then blatantly chooses to disregard it. I think if you try or depending on the media we select, Gender/sexuality fits into his categories as well (and are often hard to ignore), but I didn’t see that acknowledged strongly from Bulman’s trope discussion either. I will hold this opinion close, but also respect that Bulman’s list and observations were indeed incredibly accurate having watched the films and in-class material. He had a sample of over 100 films, and trying to understand those tropes as consistently and precise as possible does lead to a lot of generalizations- but like I critiqued before I do doubt his samples were diverse enough for how much was out at the time of publication if he still chose to brush of gender and race.
    The idea of “student agency” and “exceeding expectations” has played out the most in all the media we’ve consumed to me, from Riley’s activism in Girl Meets World, the rise above unique circumstances that “hold one back” in CODA, down to the absurd mishaps of Ferris Bueller’s or “Student Status” hierarchies of movies like Clueless/Mean Girls.

    ReplyDelete


  25. I think Bulman makes a good point about how Hollywood movies influence the way people view high school. A lot of movies show high school as a place where students deal with social pressure, friendships, popularity, and struggles outside the classroom. I agree that movies can reflect real situations students experience, especially when it comes to social class and how students are treated differently. However, I think one weakness is that Hollywood sometimes makes teachers look like they can solve every student’s problems. Real life is more complicated than that, and students also need support from their families, communities, and schools. Overall, I think Bulman’s ideas are important because movies can shape how people understand high school, but we should remember that Hollywood does not always show the full reality.

    ReplyDelete

August 20…Popculture

Was Delaney’s definition of popculture new to you? Comment on your relationship with popculture. Have you been able to find ways to bring an...