Please blog a bit about documentaries as an art form/mode of teaching and learning. You can write about whatever you choose…some possibilities: the documentarian’s role in shaping the presentation of reality, their potential to create social change, their relationship to other forms of pop culture.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
August 20…Popculture
Was Delaney’s definition of popculture new to you? Comment on your relationship with popculture. Have you been able to find ways to bring an...
-
Was Delaney’s definition of popculture new to you? Comment on your relationship with popculture. Have you been able to find ways to bring an...
-
Find something (an idea, a claim, an argument, etc.) in Bulman Ch 1 to disagree with. Explain what it is and shy you disagree with it. N...
-
What other classes have you had in which individualism was discussed? How was it talked about? Is it seen largely as a good thing or a bad t...
I think documentaries are an important art form for teaching and learning because they focus on real people, events, and issues happening in the world. Most documentaries have a purpose behind them, whether that is to educate people, raise awareness, or get a particular message across. They allow viewers to learn about experiences and situations they may not have known much about before. However, I also think it is important to recognize that the person creating the documentary can shape how reality is presented. Since they are responsible for producing, directing, and choosing what information to include, their perspective can influence how the audience understands the topic.
ReplyDeleteI also believe documentaries have the potential to create social change. For example, a documentary can expose an injustice, show the effects it has on a community, and explain how people have responded through activism, protest, or other forms of resistance. By showing these experiences to a wider audience, documentaries can encourage people to question what they previously believed or become more aware of issues that are often overlooked. In this way, documentaries are not just a way to share information but can also encourage people to think critically about society and consider what needs to change.
I also see a connection between documentaries and other forms of pop culture, especially social media. Documentaries often aim to represent real experiences and show people a more realistic view of the world. Social media can also be used to share real experiences, but I think it sometimes struggles to do this because people can create fake identities or present an idealized version of their lives. Social media has become its own culture where people may feel pressure to appear a certain way rather than show who they really are. Although documentaries can also be influenced by the perspectives of their creators, I think they can provide a deeper opportunity to understand real experiences beyond what we usually see online. Overall, documentaries remind us that learning about the world involves looking beyond appearances, questioning the information we receive, and considering perspectives different from our own.
I think documentaries are a powerful form of art because they allow people to learn about real life experiences, social issues, and different perspectives. Unlike fictional movies documentaries are based on real people and events which can help viewers develop a better understanding of the world around them. However documentarians also have a responsibility because the way they edit footage, choose interviews, and present information can influence how audiences interpret reality. Documentaries can also create social change by raising awareness about important issues and encouraging people to think differently. I believe documentaries are an important way to educate people, share meaningful stories, and inspire conversations about issues that matter in society.
ReplyDeleteI think documentaries are a fantastic way to expand the public's knowledge of a given topic, although I've felt a bit of tension with the idea that we've been throwing around in class that a documentary should contain a stable message of activism or awareness about an issue. I think this trait only really applies to certain subgenres of documentaries, like ones seeking call-to-action or written to point out a problem.
ReplyDeleteI may be a bit of a nerd for this, but my favorite kind of documentaries are music documentaries. These outline the creation of albums, the history of different scenes, or may be some type of biography of an artist/band. Music docos often don't have a particular thesis statement, as unless they're addressing a particular moment or controversy, they're only seeking to dive deeper into the psyche or scene of a band and their history. These documentaries gather a pool of knowledge and interviews, compiled more into an open discussion, or collection of stories, rather than trying to prove something. This style offers a lot of merit to me, however, as the discussion elements really paint a picture of not only the history but the interpersonal motivations that may have contributed to their songwriting (this obviously goes for any artist, not just musicians). I think you could argue that they're proving that the subject of the documentary is worth attention, and they certainly provide a much greater depth of knowledge on these artists' history, as they often ask people directly involved, most of the time including the subject of the documentary. This style of conversational storytelling is often much more eye-opening to me, as it feels more like you're being spoken to than being a passive witness. I also think it's an undersaturated method for the genre of nonfiction as a whole, as the books I've read which is also represented in this style ("Please Kill Me" by Gillian McCain and Legs McNeil) also had a greater personal impact than writing simply narrating.
Aside from this subgenre in particular, I especially admire any documentary in which the narration is performed by the subject, whether it's through interview questions or stories. Even if it isn't autobiographical, I think hearing the story through the subject's point of view, even if somewhat manipulated by the editors/directors, makes it feel much more intentional. My group pointed this out when we watched Mr. Sunshine.
On that note of manipulation, it must not be done to twist the words of the subject or make assumptions about them. One documentary, Montage of Heck (a documentary about Kurt Cobain) which I actually really loved artistically, used his own audio diary entries as narration for most of the film. The problem here, however, is that they staged fictional stories he wrote as real things that he did, despite them not being anything too unordinary, these stories were accompanied by artist animations of him doing these things, treating them as fact, despite people close to him denying that they ever happened. They also staged his life as exceedingly depressing, and overdramatized several of his stories that actually were true, once again using artist interpretations to show what was happening despite going off of audio descriptions. The entire movie was beautifully done, but incredibly disingenuous. Kurt's personal friend Buzz Osborne claimed that "90%" of it was bullshit, and even though this can be expected a little more for a film about someone no longer alive, even Kurt's mother and sister were unhappy with the film's result, as they said their words felt twisted to assist a more depressing narrative. It seemed as though they wanted him to feel deep, but in a way that would feel more depressing than authentic.
Rant aside, I believe documentaries work the best when they rely on dialogue from others, rather than stating things objectively (unless they're scientifically based), although there is a fine line between manipulating lines for tone and delivery, and manipulating lines to fabricate themes for your own agenda.
Oops, I forgot my name! This was Mietta Gearon
DeleteI think documentaries are an important form of art because it can combine education about almost anything and entertainment. It allows the viewer to basically see what the author is depicting and almost feel the emotional weight of the documentary. They also have a way of immersing the viewer in the documentary. It makes the whole thing feel more personal and impactful to the viewer. One thing I find interesting about documentaries is that the filmmaker plays a major role in shaping how reality is presented in the documentary.
ReplyDeleteI think documentaries are a really interesting subsection of film and popculture because they differ so much from other media. They take a more serious tone than most movies do, but are often much less popular than movies. I also think that documentaries are a great way to gain the public's interest on participating in social change. Because documentaries are often serious within their tones and topics, they often open the viewers eyes to a certain social issue that they haven't considered much or at all before watching. The tone used in the documentary, the cliffhangers, and the music all play a part in evoking the viewer's desire for social change regarding the discussed topic.
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeleteI think that documentaries are a form of art that most people don’t talk about enough. I feel that documentaries should be looked at more because they show a real side to the topic. With a documentary it’s real and you don’t have to worry about the true meaning behind everything going on. When it comes to documentaries also the documentarians role is a huge part of the film. The documentarian basically runs everything and a sudden change in tone or color definitely shares a message to the audience. Social influence is involved in doctumenteries. I feel that some if not most documentaries are used to educate people whether it be a positive or negative documentary. Its idea is still to inform others of what they might be watching. Documentaries can help shape people socially through the information presented in the film. For example I started watching this documentary last year called Central Park 5 and until I had sat down and got to watch it I had no idea about this case and how much of an impact it made on the community. However after sitting down and watching the documentary all the way through I got to see the case and how the men felt throughout their investigation. Overall documentaries are a form of art that allow us to see into the reality of others and other things around us.
I think documentaries are a good way to learn about real-life events and issues because they let you see things from different perspectives. Sometimes, actually seeing people talk about their experiences makes a topic feel more real than just reading about it. I also think documentaries can bring attention to issues that people might not know much about and get people to think differently about certain topics.
ReplyDeleteAt the same time, I think it's important to remember that documentaries don't always show the full picture. The person making the documentary decides what to include, what to leave out, and how to tell the story. Because of that, the way something is presented can influence how people understand it. With that being said, I think documentaries can be a really powerful way to teach people and bring awareness to important issues. They can get people talking about things they might not normally think about and even change how they see the world. I think that's what makes documentaries interesting because you're learning about real people and situations while also getting the chance to look at things from a different point of view.
I really enjoyed this documentary. It was really interesting to learn more about mariachi bands and how much they contrasted from the musical experience I had back in high school. A lot of the scenes in this really reminded me of those years. Whether it be the stress of preparing for a competition or the memorable remarks made by my teacher. It was also nice to see how the documentary segwayed more into the personal lives of these students. It still surprises me to realize that these performances were all done by high school students. It felt like I was listening to professional performances. On top of that, seeing how much time and effort went into getting ready for a competition was really cool to see. Fundraisers used to raise money and outfits personally made for each member of the varsity team show how serious this opportunity was. It also was why it felt even worse when they didn’t win their first competition. When it came to the state competition the buildup was really good. I could feel the pressure from across the screen and the way the producers emphasized this point with the sudden change in music on the empty stage. However after their performance it was revealed that they got second place. Pairing the feeling of success with the feelings of graduation was a deadly combo, I nearly teared up. But regardless it was a good documentary that did feel like your usual underdog story, however in this case it was about real people in a real school setting, which adds more emotions for the viewer than one would expect.
ReplyDeleteoops I misinterpreted the question here is a blog post that answers the question:
DeleteI believe that documentaries are an interesting way to tell the viewer about nonfiction events. At first when I thought of non-fiction works I would usually think of new reports or lab reports, and I wouldn't really think of documentaries. I believe that documentaries have become more focused on engaging the audience rather than entirely being about the truth. Even when I watched the documentary for my project, it felt like I was watching a movie plot that just happened to be about real people rather than the other way around. It shapes the story in a way to make it one digestible for the viewer, but also entertaining. There’s just so much power the producers have when it comes to making a documentary, a simple change in music can really alter the theme of the song and make it impossible for the viewer to make their own opinions without being slightly changed from how the information is presented. Regardless I do think documentaries do a good job in presenting topics that don’t get as much recognition as they should, having your story be told may be more beneficial than being picky on how it is told.
My documentary was incredibly insightful into the disenfranchisement of black girls in public school and how their own teachers see them as the enemy. Multiple instances were spoken about by the victims of these ignorant school districts and people associated within the schools. It was interesting to learn about how black girls are entirely more likely to be referred to law enforcement, or be kicked out of school and forced into the criminal justice system because of societal expectation and lack of help from adults. I believe that it exposed the social ignorance many students and teachers may have in regards to how to treat black little girls who exhibit the same behavioral issues as their white counterparts. These girls are punished more severely and oftentimes pushed out (hence the name of the documentary). I watched this documentary with one of my friends and throughout, we often were at a loss for words at the graphic imagery and victim statements we were shown. The only thing we could say really was "this is so depressing"--as so many black girls go through this while just trying to get an education. There was an immense emphasis on getting young women help and accessibility towards learning without them having to deal with racism, xenophobia, sexism, classism, and a myriad of other debilitating bigotry taught into our society and exposed upon vulnerable children. It also opened my eyes to the lack of discussion there was around black girls in school. As oftentimes, people would rather talk about the school to prison pipeline in regards to boys.
ReplyDeleteDocumentaries have always been immensely educational and motivating for me. I am just as susceptible as everyone else to the techniques documentaries use to hook you, and maybe that is why I like them so much. I will say, I don’t often voluntarily sit down to watch one. It’s hard to get into the mindset of receiving a lot of information, and I feel like a lot of documentaries shed light on serious issues. Recently our discussions about documentaries have had me thinking about what they omit, who is controlling the narrative, and how the stylistic choices they’re making influence how we feel. Documentaries have an immense role in shaping the viewer's perception of reality. Up until now, I kind of approached documentaries as fact, as “nonfiction” like the first quote presented on our first day of the unit. I’m sure a lot of people watch documentaries without a critical eye just as I have, which is why I think docs have an obligation to fully interrogate the subject they are covering and maintain ethical standards. Documentaries can also have a big hand in generating social change. 13th is a 2016 documentary on Netflix that explores the history of racial inequality and mass incarceration in the United States. This did a lot to educate me with statistics, real testimonies, talking heads from scholars and field experts, and real historical footage. Netflix is the most popular streaming platform, and I’m sure millions have now watched it. Even if people knew much of the information in the documentary separately, it’s different to have it all presented in succession—this creates a larger narrative around the subject and a coherent idea that people can leave with.
ReplyDeleteI found the documentary I watched, Precious Knowledge, to be very interesting and relative to today's political climate. This documentary was was filmed during the Obama administration and times of racism in classrooms seems to stay a hot topic still. Although this documentary is 15 years old this year, Hispanic people are, what some would argue, at an even worse risk of safety than before. With ICE raids and ICE being present outside of schools to try and "catch" undocumented immigrants, the safety of academic atmospheres has declined. The far right republican racist agendas that are being pushed by our own president prove that there is changes that need to be enforced. I just thought it was interesting that this documentary is still so prevalent in today's political climate even though it's 15 years old.
ReplyDeleteThis documentary brought up another tough political topic of being the idea of "indoctrination" in schools. From where I am from in Loudoun County, it seems there is always some new discourse on indoctrinated students and about learning things like "critical race theory." A prime example I can think of is how this year LCPS introduced a new curriculum of LGBTQ+ related awareness lessons to be taught in advisory (which is like homeroom). The internet blew up and words like "indoctrination" and "propaganda" were being thrown around. This was extremely frustrating to me as a former student at LCPS and queer identifying person myself, because the awareness of our identities isn't "propaganda" or "indoctrination." There is no such thing in schools as forcing kids to learn a specific mindset. Learning about the diversity of our country built on different identities is not "indoctrination," and I like that this documentary brought that up and handled it very eloquently.
Documentary can shed a lot of light on a lot of things like mental health, social injustice, hidden truths, etc. All these things that you can learn from documentaries can help people to better understand reality. I think people, the youth especially, are so desensitized to actual real life issues from things they've watched. There are a lot of people who don't know what's going on with politics and chose not to vote or educate themselves on what's currently going on in the world, which is very sad to hear. I know for a fact that they don't watch documentaries because if they did they would be so wilfully ignorant. There are a plethora of documentaries out there, some talk about social injustice while others talk about mental health. Both things are serious topics and are explained in documentaries as such which allows the watcher/audience to get a good grasp on reality.
ReplyDeleteThe documentary I watched was The Librarians, and the topic was very melancholic and somber, which I think the documentary showed off quite well. It sets the mood accordingly and you feel the severity of what's happening which keeps you invested. The documentarian aimed to present the importance of what's going on with book bans and the social injustices being displayed by the banning. I think the documentary does really well in uncovering these topics and events.
ReplyDeleteI think documentaries are simply just a different mode of learning, like an alternative to a textbook or news article, that might be enjoyable and preferred by some people because of the creative choices the director chose. Music, camera angles, lighting, the interviewee and how they're interviewed, and reenactments, or footage into the subjects personal life can really make a documentary more than the material. And I believe because of how some are directed, the viewers may be able to grapple on to the topic and conversation being had compared to them reading about the topic in scholar textbook.
ReplyDeleteI definitly think that documentaries are an important form of media, I feel as though it brings more awareness to topics that may need to be talked about. It is a great way to shed light on cases that people might not have been aware of before and in a way I believe it is a quicker way to get information.
ReplyDeleteTo me, documentaries are informational and interesting although it depends on the genre and the overall premise of the film. Sometimes I watch true crime documentaries, and most of the time they do a good job at putting you on the edge of your seat and keeping you interested. Last class, someone brought up how sometimes true crime documentaries are exploitative of the victims and their families, and I very much agree! With this specific genre, it is hard to balance ethics and "good film making." -Hannah S
ReplyDeleteDocumentaries in my opinion are very interesting and is a great way to inform people about real life situation and issues to help them see things from another point of view. I used to watch a lot of WWE documentaries on netflix growing up and it gave a lot of inside information and a lot of knowledge about the older generations of the WWF. - Brendan Patac
ReplyDeleteDocumentaries are a really interesting way to investigate topics and share them publicly. They are often all the research of an academic paper paired with the artistic vision of camera work, lighting, sound design, and other visuals. Documentaries are a special type of research because almost always they require the researcher to be directly involved with their subject. When you write a research paper about, for example, the realities of women in Texas who are trying to seek out abortion, you can read testimonies and papers. You analyze those sources and synthesize them into your own paper. Perhaps you conduct an interview over the phone. If you were to make a *documentary* about women in Texas trying to seek out abortion, you would have to *go* to Texas and interview women directly, and possibly follow them through their journey. It's far more personal and allows the viewer to truly *see* this reality, rather than if they were to simply read about it.
ReplyDeleteJosephine btw
DeleteI think documentaries are an important way to educate the public and spread awareness about a certain topic. Documentaries are a very entertaining way to present research found and a way around having people read the articles themselves, because most people have very limited attention spans and do not feel like reading in general. I also think documentaries can be used as a form of protest and speak out against certain issues. It is also a way to shed light onto these topics.
ReplyDeleteI love documentaries as a form of learning! This whole class has been talking about how pop cultural media internalizes lessons in us, and by recognizing the value in film, we can therefore recognize the value in documentaries as well. There is something special and artistic about showing the data or non-fictional story through this method. People are quick to relegate documentaries as something dumb or boring, but I do not agree whatsoever!
ReplyDeleteI think documentaries are a great way of teaching and learning because they allow people to understand real-life situations and experiences. Instead of just reading about something in a textbook, you can actually see and hear the stories of people who experienced it. Documentaries can also change the way people think by bringing attention to important issues in society. They can educate people, create awareness, and sometimes motivate people to make a difference. I also think documentaries connect to pop culture because they use storytelling, music, interviews, and visuals to keep people interested. Overall, documentaries are important because they help people learn about the world from different perspectives and understand things they might not have experienced themselves.
ReplyDeleteI think documentaries are of course made for educational purposes but are also an amazing opportunity to express your story through art and abstract ways; it can encourage deeper thinking. In addition, art can lure the viewer even more, possibly convincing the person to care more about the topic due to the enticement of the art within the documentary. Art is known for moving people; therefore, I think it is very important to include and can really help the viewers visually and emotionally connect to the meaning of the documentary on a deeper level.
ReplyDeleteI think documentaries are a good way to teach people about real life events and the things going on in the world. I think they're important because they help people learn about things they might not have known about before. They're a good way to see different perspectives and see what others have gone through. I think it can also bring attention to certain issues that don't get talked about enough. I think overall that documentaries are a great way to educate people and bring awareness to important issues.
ReplyDelete