Find something recent from the news about book banning/censorship. You can relate it to the New Kid situation or feel free to write about anything you want to think about/discuss related to the topic.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
August 20…Popculture
Was Delaney’s definition of popculture new to you? Comment on your relationship with popculture. Have you been able to find ways to bring an...
-
Was Delaney’s definition of popculture new to you? Comment on your relationship with popculture. Have you been able to find ways to bring an...
-
Find something (an idea, a claim, an argument, etc.) in Bulman Ch 1 to disagree with. Explain what it is and shy you disagree with it. N...
-
What other classes have you had in which individualism was discussed? How was it talked about? Is it seen largely as a good thing or a bad t...
I came across an article from the UAB Institute for Human Rights Blog titled “The Rising Tide of Book Bans in American Schools,” published on March 5, 2026. Something that stood out to me was the pattern of books being challenged or banned, especially those that focus on LGBTQ+ experiences, racial identity, and systemic inequalities. I think it is particularly important to highlight how LGBTQ+ topics seem to be becoming an increasingly significant focus of book banning compared to previous conversations that centered more heavily on race and racial representation.
ReplyDeleteI think this connects to the political climate we have been experiencing in the United States. Before the political shift we saw with the so-called "blue wave" on November 3rd, the country seemed to be moving further toward conservative political values, which also brought increased attention to LGBTQ+ rights and representation. I think there is a connection between the pushback against LGBTQ+ rights, including same-sex marriage, and the growing efforts to remove books that discuss LGBTQ+ identities and experiences. To me, this is concerning because books allow people to learn about experiences and perspectives that may be different from their own. Removing these stories limits representation and can make people feel as though their identities are something that should be hidden or censored. I think it is important to recognize and discuss this pattern because students deserve access to books that represent different communities, identities, and experiences. This is something that needs to change rather than continue becoming normalized.
ReplyDeleteWhen I was researching, I found this article about a judge in Maryland trying to return to a banned graphic novel called Flamer. This book talked about sexuality, religion, bullying, and mental health as a whole. There were a lot of students, faculty,and parents, who reviewed the book, and after looking into the book more, most agreed this book should stay in libraries. However the school board still decided that this book be removed and that it wasn’t “fit” to be on the shelves of libraries. After a long battle, the judge decided that the school board was violating rights and the reasoning behind why they wanted the book banned just seemed unreasonable. This also violated Maryland's Freedom to Read Act and the judge decided this book should continue to be in libraries. This reminded me of New Kid, because like Flamer it talked about topics that people aren’t always comfortable talking about. I believe that it’s unfair to take a book off of a shelf because it doesn't fit someone else’s idea about what is an "appropriate" book. Even if the book can’t relate to everyone, these themes are things that need to be talked about and not everyone is as educated on these matters as they should be. Overall I think that students should have an area to learn about real life issues and important life lessons that we all need to be educated on. I believe graphic novels are a really good way to expose young children to things that they may or may not have to experience. I feel taking away these books/resources also doesn’t allow for this type of education to be explored. I believe that some graphic novels can share a message to everyone, especially one that can be easily interpreted and something that everyone should be educated on.
Mikayla Blackman-Jones
DeleteI found an article from the ACLU New Jersey titles "Banning Books is an Act of Censorship and it Can Take Many Forms – Here’s How to Spot it." Where they talk about how censorship isn't limited to just removing a book form a shelf. It also includes "soft censorship" which is basically moving books to less accessible areas of the library or requiring a parents permission. It also highlights how book bans not only suppress creativity, but it also erases the lived experiences of the authors and readers. The article notes that 30% of uniquely banned titles nationwide were books on race, racism, characters of color, while 26% were on LGBTQ+ characters/themes. Lastly the article has a point about the 1st amendment and how people have the right to avoid ideas and beliefs they disagree with, but they don't have the right to impose their beliefs onto the rest of the community. Falling more towards freedom of speech or freedom of press under the 1st amendment.
ReplyDeleteI read an article from PEN America called a Spotlight on School Book Bans. The article talks about how book banning continues to be a problem in American schools, and according to the article, they say that almost 12,000 books were banned through this past school year. I found it interesting how a lot of those books had to do with topics like race and different identities. I think this connects to New Kid because the book shows some of the challenges that Black students can go through in school when they are the minority. It's interesting how people tried to get New Kid removed from schools completely because of how it talks about racism. I don't think books should get banned just because they discuss certain topics that are real and make people uncomfortable.
ReplyDeletehttps://journals.ala.org/index.php/jifp/article/view/7208/10293
ReplyDeleteThis is a history of censorship in America. You said news, but here's my thing: I feel like since this talks about different court cases which I am sure were on the news at some point I am going to count it :). I think the viewpoint that interests me the most about censorship/book banning is how clearly that should be prevented by the first amendment. America is extremely relaxed with our free speech in a way I actually really appreciate. I do believe government can play a big role in our lives, but I don't want the power to regulate speech willy-nilly falling into the hands of whatever politician is in charge of that at the time. That's so stressful. Anyway, I believe the founders had a lot of foresight. I also believe the texts they drew on to emphasize the freedom of speech would not support book banning or censorship either (like John Stuart Mill's "On Liberty," specifically the marketplace of ideas). Also, if I am not mistaken, book banning or censorship literally cannot be possible. The United States has actually a very messed up history of the freedom of speech court cases. In 1919, we decided that handing out pamphlets supporting communism would be like shouting fire in an open theater. THEN in 1969, we decided that as long as they didn't make a specific plan, the KKK could utter hateful speech. It is actually so bizarre. If the KKK has the right to the freedom of speech, I believe books like "New Kid" or other books they were trying to ban in the documentaries can stay up on the shelves. I think that promotes a more diverse set of ideas, and hopefully we are smart enough as a nation to choose the right thing and absolutely destroy KKK rhetoric.
I think book banning has a negative impact because it limits what students can learn and understand about the world. Books expose readers to different cultures, experiences, and perspectives. When books are banned, students lose the opportunity to learn about important topics like racism, discrimination, and equality. I also think banning books can make students feel like their stories and experiences do not matter. Instead of removing books because they discuss uncomfortable topics, we should use them as opportunities to learn and have meaningful conversations.
ReplyDeleteI read an article by AP that was about book bannings being at a record high in 2025, but what caught my attention was “For decades, challenges to a given book came from a parent or another member of a local community. But in recent years, the ALA has found, the trend has shifted sharply to government officials and such conservative activists as Moms for Liberty…’in 2025 book bannings we’re not sparked by concerned parents…they were part of a well well funded, politically driven campaign.’ “. Government officials and political groups with agendas are pulling books from school libraries that don’t fit what they believe children should know about. They are putting their beliefs before the wants and concerns of students, schools, and parents. Their concern isn’t children being exposed to graphic violence in kindergarten, it’s children being exposed to real issues like sex trafficking and racism, and viewpoints, and learning about different people like immigrants or foreigners, queer people, poc, or Nazis, terrorists and hate groups. They want these kids to be ignorant to real life because real life doesn’t support the story they’re trying to push.
ReplyDeleteAs I was exploring different recent instances of book bannings, I was most intrigued by the Department of Education's Press Release from 2025, titled: "U.S. Department of Education Ends Biden’s Book Ban Hoax." Obviously, book bannings have been occurring for years now, I remember when it came to my own school district and going to school board meetings with my brother, and even in-person, the people attempting to remove books are very proud of the term "book-banning," which makes this disturbingly propagandized article even more alarming as it repeatedly says "so-called 'book-banning'" whenever it's brought up. Another humorous point is that this article was published in January of 2025, on a date while Biden was still a lame duck, and before Trump was inaugurated. Despite this, they refer to Biden as "then-President Biden," and described Trump as not only "discovering," but terminated their efforts to "train schools to deter schools from limiting student access to sexually graphic or racially divisive books" as well as encouraging Title IX and VI complaints from students.
ReplyDeleteI personally just find it fascinating to read the fear-mongering wording that's pushed by this department, especially considering that they deny book bannings altogether. They state that books are not being banned, and that they're simply using "commonsense processes," and that the idea of a "book ban" is a false narrative fabricated by Biden. Simultaneously, however, PEN education recorded 6,870 instances of book bans across 23 states and 87 public school districts in the exact school year this press release was published. I really just feel that it's important to really evaluate the arguments made by this opposition, as a lot of what our government officials push are blatant lies and falsities, although they stir concerns in conservative America that woulds seem legitimately troubling if heard without context. It's really important to compare these books' reason to be banned with their actual content warnings, explicit content and context around their inclusion, as almost none of them actually expose children to anything distressing.
I found an article by PEN America and they stated that, they recorded nearly 12,000 books being banned bans in a single school year. Books dealing with topics like race/racism, gender identity and sexuality where the most challenged books among the ones that where banned. It also states that there have been some schools that have been using AI to help with removing books. One thing I find worth discussing is the difference between parents making choices for their own children and removing access for everyone. If a parent believes a book isn't appropriate for their child, that's a personal decision. But when a book is removed from a school library entirely, other students lose the opportunity to read it and decide for themselves. I also believe that this connects directly to New Kid. It has also faced challenges and removal attempts in some districts because it discusses race, identity, and belonging.
ReplyDeleteThroughout my recent findings I found that the common reason in which books get banned is mainly due to how the reader views it. For example some examples were explained in the “the Librarian” documentary in which they explained how some books get framed as inappropriate for students and how the parents use this as ammunition to get the librarian in trouble. It’s more infuriating since most of the time these books tend to just be framed on specific parts of their books rather than the actual message they are trying to portray. However this really just negatively impacts the readers who read the most. Preventing them from the freedom of literature doesn't do any good for them.
ReplyDeleteWhen looking for recent news regarding book bans, I found that PBS was reporting on a recent Supreme Court Case in which they declined to hear an appeal on a Texas book ban case which would've allowed officials to remove certain books from libraries. I've noticed that a lot of the people who bring up these bans are independent groups within communities that don't really have anything to do with the schools aside from their child may attend there. It's predatory to use your children as a means of evidence in obtaining books which could be considered "inappropriate" for depicting LGBTQ+, sex education, or other forms deemed "inappropriate". However, some lower circuit courts in Texas did seem to think that it wasn't a violation of the constitutional right to free speech, despite it directly foreboding speech? My own school my senior year was facing backlash, as the librarians went on a bit of a strike and put up all the locally banned books up in the display case. Which freaked out the parents of students. Meanwhile, most of my peers didn't even seem to notice or care that much. It's interesting to see that the students aren't the forefront of this issue, but rather the parents who don't attend the school whatsoever.
ReplyDeleteAngel Comas btw!
DeleteI saw a story on instagram from PEN America. It talked about the Florida department of education encouraged schools to basically do what happened with New Kid. They wanted the schools to review all the books in their libraries and see if they have topics like race or gender identity and other stuff like that. I saw this was like New Kid because the book talked about themes like stereotypes and racism. I think every student should be able to explore what ever stories they want to and even if those stories have some difficult subjects, it is their choice to keep on reading.
ReplyDeleteThis is Brendan Patac
DeleteI found a recent article from PEN America about book censorship in Florida. The article discusses how Florida is encouraging school districts to review their library collections and potentially remove books that have been challenged or banned in other districts. Several organizations are pushing back because they believe this limits students' access to different perspectives and ideas.
ReplyDeleteWhat stood out to me is how book banning can affect what students are exposed to and what they're able to learn about. It also made me think about New Kid and how important it is for students to see different backgrounds and experiences represented in the books they read. I feel like students should have the opportunity to learn about things they might not personally experience or understand. Just because a topic makes someone uncomfortable doesn't mean it shouldn't be discussed. I understand parents having concerns about certain books, but I don't think that means everyone should lose access to them.